The B.C. Human Rights Tribunal just dropped a major ruling, straight up ordering LifeLabs and its subsidiary Excelleris Technologies to shell out $32,000 for ‘injury to dignity’ suffered by three transgender and non-binary patients. This ain’t no small potatoes, folks; it’s a critical moment for accountability regarding LifeLabs misgendering practices and how healthcare providers handle gender identity. According to the report, the incidents went down in 2019 at service centers in Vancouver and Burnaby, and the tribunal member, Theressa Etmanski, was not playing around.
One of the most glaring cases involved Noa Moses, who, according to the tribunal decision, faced a legit nightmare trying to get basic lab services. Moses, a non-binary individual, brought a doctor’s requisition form in October 2019 that didn’t specify ‘M’ or ‘F.’ But instead of handling it with discretion, staff reportedly grilled Moses repeatedly about their gender in front of a whole waiting room. Talk about a public spectacle, right? Moses testified they weren’t offered a private space, and even after stating they were neither male nor female multiple times, staff kept pushing, even threatening to refuse service if a binary gender wasn’t picked. Moses felt ‘exhausted and upset,’ ultimately pointing to a letter just to get the process moving, which is just messed up, periodt.
Devan Snow’s experience, as highlighted by the tribunal, wasn’t any less infuriating. The report states that LifeLabs apparently wouldn’t let Snow update his gender identity in their system, sticking instead with the sex assigned at birth. Imagine having your identity erased every time you try to get medical care. To make matters worse, Snow, too, was forced to discuss his gender identity at the counter in a packed waiting area at a Burnaby location, again in October 2019. He described feeling ‘othered and unimportant’ and super embarrassed because his personal details became a ‘huge thing’ for everyone to overhear. This kind of public outing isn’t just awkward; as the tribunal noted, it can put people at serious risk, which hits different when you think about patient safety and privacy.
Then there’s Vincent Viezzer’s ordeal in Vancouver, also in 2019, which, while different, still packed a punch. Even though his gender marker was already typed as ‘M,’ the article states staff added ‘FTM’ to his form. Viezzer understood this as ‘Female to Male’ and had a strong emotional reaction, scribbling it out and leaving without getting his blood drawn. While some might think ‘FTM’ isn’t a biggie, the tribunal’s Etmanski pointed out that such initials, even if not ‘egregious or virulent’ to everyone, can be ‘oversimplified and inaccurate’ for a trans person’s lived experience. The ruling stressed that something doesn’t need to be universally offensive to be discriminatory, which is a key takeaway, for real.
The tribunal’s decision extends beyond just the payout. LifeLabs was also slapped with orders to correct the misgendering of Moses and Snow and, crucially, to ensure transgender and non-binary patients have a private space for discussing sex or gender within six months. This is a game-changer, setting a precedent that patient dignity and privacy are non-negotiable. Furthermore, the company has to roll out comprehensive training on trans and non-binary patient privacy for all B.C. staff and management within a year. This isn’t just about fixing past wrongs; it’s about future-proofing healthcare services to be more inclusive and respectful. It’s about time, if you ask me.
This ruling is a clear message: healthcare providers have a responsibility to create safe and affirming environments for all patients. The financial penalties, while significant, are just one piece of the puzzle. The mandatory policy changes and training are where the real impact will be felt, hopefully ensuring that no one else has to endure such demeaning experiences when seeking essential medical care. It’s a wake-up call for the entire industry, reminding everyone that respecting identity isn’t just good practice; it’s a fundamental human right. Periodt.
If you enjoyed this article, share it with your friends or leave us a comment!
Adrian Velk is a global affairs journalist focused on breaking news, geopolitics, and societal trends. With a sharp eye for detail and a commitment to accuracy, he delivers timely reporting that helps readers understand the fast-moving world around them. His work blends factual depth with clear storytelling, making complex events accessible to a broad audience.
