Why Lovie Smith called for a Texans punt late in OT to seal a tie vs. Colts: ‘A tie was better than a loss’

Week 1 of the 2022 NFL season featured lots of chaos, but there can’t be true chaos in the league without a tie. The Texans and Colts fit the bill, with the AFC South showdown ending 20-20 after a scoreless 10-minute overtime.

It was a gritty, grueling game that meant different things for each team. For the Texans, it was an indication that perhaps they aren’t as bad most thought coming into the year. For the Colts, it showed they have a lot of work to do.

It took a bit of luck for this game to end in a draw. The Colts’ true final drive of the game was a knock-down drag-out affair. Indianapolis moved to the Houston 24 after 13-play, 45-yard drive that took 6:30 off the clock. The Texans were only saved by Rodrigo Blankenship missing a 42-yard field goal kick.

MORE: Tyreek Hill praises Mike McDaniel for gutsy calls in Dolphins’ win over Patriots

Houston eventually gave the Colts the ball back with 20 seconds remaining after punting on fourth-and-3 from the Indianapolis 49. The Texans effectively conceded a tie. While not perfect math, the Surrender Index graded the punt harshly.

MORE: Week 1 was horrible for a lot of NFL kickers: A look at the lowlights

So, why would the Texans do something like that? Put simply: Coach Lovie Smith was surrendering.

“I felt like a tie was better than a loss in that situation,” Smith told reporters after the game, per Yahoo. “It’s a decision that you make. If you would guarantee that we were going to get (the first down), then it was good. But if you miss it right there and they had stuffed us on the play, they have one play and they’re in (field goal) position.”

Smith called back to his team’s struggles on the previous Colts drive.

“It’s not like we were playing our best defense at the time,” he said. “We were drained. We were gassed a little bit. That’s how it goes. In an ideal world, you don’t want a loss, you want a win, but if you can’t get the win, sometimes you settle for the tie. A lot of football left to go in the season.”

Not everyone on the Texans agreed with Smith’s take.

“We’re devastated,” offensive lineman Laremy Tunsil said, per Click2Houston. “It feels like we took an L, but it’s better than a loss. It was our fault. There’s some things on film we’ve got to fix. We’ve got 24 hours to let it go. You’ve got to give respect to us. You’ve got to earn it.”

“It’s very bittersweet,” said defensive end Ogbo Okoronkwo. “We’ve been working really hard and we wanted to get a win and finish the game out. We didn’t get it done, but a lot of bright spots.”

While none of this means much for Smith’s long-term prospects in Houston, it is an ominous start to his return to the NFL. The Texans’ next game will be Sept. 18 against Russell Wilson and the Broncos.

Facebook Comments Box

Hits: 0