Heads up, TV fans! Get ready to mark your calendars because something truly special is brewing over at NBC, and it’s got “must-watch” written all over it. We’re talking about none other than the incredibly talented Jake Johnson, who’s set to lead a brand-new private investigator comedy pilot. This isn’t just another show, folks; with the creative minds behind it and Johnson himself at the helm, this project is lowkey fire, promising a fresh, hilarious, and perhaps even surprisingly heartfelt take on the classic L.A. detective genre. It feels like the stars have aligned for Johnson, giving him a role that seems tailor-made for his unique blend of cynical charm and underlying vulnerability.
Johnson will be stepping into the shoes of Mickey, a private investigator who sounds like he walked straight out of a Raymond Chandler novel but with a modern, broken twist. The character description paints a picture of a man who is “smart, cynical and heartbroken, but trying to pretend he’s not.” Mickey was formerly an LAPD cop whose life imploded three years ago, pushing him into the world of private detection. For real, this sounds like the kind of role Johnson was born to play. Anyone who’s been following his career knows he excels at portraying guys who are rough around the edges, quick with a sarcastic remark, but deep down, totally lovable and worth rooting for.
The pilot boasts some serious creative firepower behind the scenes. It’s being co-written and executive produced by Dan Goor and Luke Del Tredici, the masterminds who brought us the critically acclaimed and fan-favorite “Brooklyn Nine-Nine.” If you’ve seen that show, you know these dudes are absolute wizards when it comes to blending sharp, character-driven comedy with compelling procedural elements. They built an entire universe around a police precinct, proving they can craft hilarious ensemble dynamics while also delivering genuinely engaging mystery-of-the-week storylines. Their involvement alone highkey guarantees a certain level of quality and a steady stream of laughs.
Adding another layer of pure gold to this project is Akiva Schaffer, who has boarded as director and executive producer. Schaffer, a member of the iconic comedy group The Lonely Island, is known for his work on films like “Popstar: Never Stop Never Stopping” and the upcoming “Naked Gun” reboot. His comedic sensibilities are straight up legendary—often leaning into parody, meta-humor, and a relentless commitment to the bit. With Schaffer directing, you can bet your bottom dollar this pilot will have a distinct visual style and a comedic rhythm that’s both clever and laugh-out-loud funny. He’s going to bring a vibe that is totally on point for what sounds like a self-aware and witty take on the detective genre.
The logline itself is a hoot: the pilot “Continues the proud tradition of Los Angeles private eyes that began with Philip Marlowe and will end with this show.” That’s some bold, hilarious self-aware humor right there, setting the tone for a show that understands its genre roots while clearly planning to put its own unique, potentially irreverent, stamp on it. Philip Marlowe, for the uninitiated, is one of the original hard-boiled detectives, a literary icon who set the standard for the cynical, moralistic private eye navigating the murky depths of L.A. This show seems poised to honor that legacy, but with a wink and a chuckle.
Johnson’s career trajectory has perfectly primed him for a role like Mickey. While many know him best as the curmudgeonly, perpetually confused writer Nick Miller from the beloved Fox sitcom “New Girl,” he’s consistently diversified his portfolio. From the animated heroics of Peter B. Parker in the critically acclaimed “Spider-Verse” films (where he brought a perfectly flawed and relatable mentor to life) to his more recent roles in the raunchy period comedy “Minx” and the animated “Hoops,” Johnson has shown incredible range. He effortlessly transitions between laugh-out-loud comedy and moments of genuine emotional depth, making him a prime candidate to lead a show that promises both.
His knack for playing relatable, slightly chaotic characters who are just trying their best (or sometimes, just barely trying) is straight up gold for a comedy PI. You need someone who can deliver snappy one-liners while also making you believe they can solve a case, even if they’re eating cold pizza for breakfast and making questionable life choices. Johnson embodies that charming loser archetype with a finesse that few others possess. The character Mickey, with his heartbreak and cynicism, sounds like a natural evolution of the “Nick Miller” persona, now with a license to investigate and a whole new set of problems to unravel.
The single-camera format for this pilot is also a significant choice. Unlike traditional multi-camera sitcoms filmed in front of a live studio audience, a single-camera setup allows for more cinematic storytelling, a faster pace, and often a more naturalistic comedic style. Think “The Office” or “Parks and Recreation”—it lets the humor breathe, allows for subtle visual gags, and can make the characters feel more grounded, even amidst absurd situations. This format is perfect for a show that’s looking to blend detective procedural elements with genuine character comedy.
It’s also interesting to note that this isn’t the only private investigator pilot currently brewing at NBC. The network is also prepping a reboot of the classic “The Rockford Files,” with David Boreanaz attached. This move signals that the Peacock network is digging into that beloved detective genre, perhaps aiming to capture audiences who appreciate a good mystery with a charismatic lead, but with diverse comedic or dramatic twists. This Jake Johnson pilot is undoubtedly the more comedic of the two, and it will be interesting to see how both projects differentiate themselves and perform.
All in all, this pilot has all the ingredients to be a major hit. The pedigree of the writers and director, combined with Jake Johnson’s undeniable talent and charisma, makes this a project to watch out for. It’s got that indie movie feel with network backing, and fans of “New Girl” who always secretly wanted to see Nick Miller solve mysteries (or at least try to) will be highkey stoked. Get ready, because Mickey, the newest L.A. private eye, is about to hit your screens, and it’s going to be a wild ride. No cap.
If you enjoyed this article, share it with your friends or leave us a comment!
